Since 2003, the San Diego Theatre Critics Circle has collectively honored local theater productions, artists and designers at the annual Craig Noel Awards. But for the second year in a row, the annual awards program has been canceled because of the pandemic.
Instead, Critics Circle members like myself are writing their own top 10 lists to honor work that might otherwise go unsung in a year when even getting the doors back open was a Herculean achievement. Here’s a look back at 10 favorite shows and performances in San Diego theater in 2021.
Best live shows
“1222 Oceanfront: A Black Family Christmas,” New Village Arts Theatre: San Diego playwright Dea Hurston’s world premiere musical offered a funny and heartwarming Christmas story from the rare perspective of an affluent Black family in modern-day Carlsbad. Directed by Delicia Turner Sonnenberg, co-conceived by Milena (Sellers) Phillips, Frankie Alicea-Ford and Kevin “Blax” Burroughs and musicalized by (Sellers) Phillips and composer John-Mark McGaha, the play was authentically Black but also universal in its themes.
“The Garden,” La Jolla Playhouse: The Playhouse reopened with this visually stunning and haunting mother-daughter drama written by and co-starring Charlayne Woodard. Woodard has a charismatic, audience-interactive stage presence, the scenic design was gorgeous and the fast-moving play, co-directed by Patricia McGregor and Delicia Turner Sonnenberg, had a twist ending I didn’t see coming.
“Ben Butler,” North Coast Repertory Theatre: Richard Strand’s play about a runaway slave seeking sanctuary at a Union fort in the early days of the Civil War doesn’t sound like a comedy, but it was both funny and dramatic in the hands of director David Ellenstein and his fine four-member cast.
“Witchland,” Backyard Renaissance Theatre: Tim Mulligan’s unique horror comedy-drama gave audiences a reason to get off their couches to experience live performances again. Directed by Andrew Oswald, this spooky and immersive world premiere play was about a family living next door to a very creepy witch, who spooked audiences by unexpectedly popping up just about everywhere inside the Tenth Avenue Arts Center.
“The Gardens of Anuncia,” The Old Globe: I loved Michael John LaChiusa’s touching and beautifully staged musical. It was inspired by the 1940s Argentina childhood of his longtime friend and collaborator, Broadway legend Graciela Daniele, who directed and co-choreographed the show. My only complaint was that I had too many unanswered questions at the end of this too-brief, 90-minute show.
“Beauty and the Beast,” Moonlight Stage Productions: One of the most spectacular shows ever produced at Vista’s Moonlight Amphitheatre, this Disney musical had a 35-member cast, epic dance numbers, lavish costumes and scenery and several standout performances. Nearly 30,000 audience members attended performances, making “Beast” — directed by Jamie Torcellini — the highest-grossing show in Moonlight’s 40-year history.
Best streaming shows
“I and You,” Moxie Theatre: Lauren Gunderson’s quirky, deeply moving and mysterious play is about a dying teenage girl who’s fighting so fiercely to stay alive, she won’t let anyone inside her heart, until a persistent classmate and the poetry of Walt Whitman eventually break through. Callie Prendiville’s stage direction transcended the usual limitations of plays on film.
“The Mountaintop,” American History Theater, The Roustabouts Theatre and Teenage Youth Performing Arts Theatre (TYPA): Katori Hall’s play, which imagines Martin Luther King’s emotionally tortured final hours before his 1968 assassination, worked particularly well on film in this well-cast production directed by Kandace Crystal.
“Nicholas, Anna and Sergei,” Hershey Felder Presents for San Diego Rep: One of more than a dozen filmed plays written, co-directed and performed by Felder since the pandemic began, this sumptuous production on the little-known life of Russian composer Sergei Rachmaninoff had an international cast, stunning location shoots in Florence, Italy, gorgeous music and even subtitles for the scenes with Russian dialogue.
“Songs for a New World,” Teatro San Diego: This year-old diversity-focused theater company impressed with its debut production, a filmed staging of Jason Robert Brown’s eclectic 1995 musical “Songs for a New World.” Director Kevin “Blax” Burroughs reimagined the scenes — about people through history about to make life-changing decisions — from a 2021 perspective.
My 10 favorite performances of 2021
- Bibi Mama in her solo play “The Mango Tree” at Moxie Theatre
- Caiel Noble in his professional theater debut as MLK in “The Mountaintop
- Jenna Lea Rosen as Belle in “Beauty and the Beast”
- Ric Salinas in San Diego Rep’s solo play “57 Chevy”
- Cynthia Gerber in Lamb’s Players Theatre’s solo play “The Belle of Amherst”
- Daren Scott as Van in “Witchland”
- Richard Baird as Ben in “Ben Butler”
- Charlayne Woodard as Cassandra in “The Garden”
- Paco Tolson as Vincent in La Jolla Playhouse’s “to the yellow house”
- Andrew Polec as the Grinch in the Old Globe’s “Dr. Seuss’s How the Grinch Stole Christmas”
Pam Kragen writes about theater for the San Diego Union-Tribune. To see other Critics Circle members’ top 10 picks for 2021, visit our Facebook page at: facebook.com/sandiegotheatrecriticscircle